September 16, 2025

Marching with the Nazis – as un-Australian as it gets

I’m still shocked by the marches and rallies around the country opposing immigration. Everyone involved says mass immigration, but it’s clear in practice they mean most immigration – and definitely all immigration by people who aren’t white, or as I like to say, ‘pink’. Here I am travelling through my own homeland once again and, at times, it seems like a foreign country – not because of immigrants but because of those who have grown up here. Those taking part in these marches probably have genuine grievances, but they have picked the wrong target to blame and, in the process, have been steered into becoming in effect neo-Nazi fellow travellers. We are (almost) all immigrants here, only just starting to genuinely come to grips with this country.

It’s not that I don’t agree with the right to demonstrate - it’s part of the fabric of democracy that many people would give their lives for. A good example is the ‘Your Rights at Work’ march in Melbourne in 2005.

What is interesting, and heartening, is that – apart from the Nazis, who don’t want any immigration – no-one else wants to publicly oppose immigration completely. No-one seems too keen to be publicly associated with organising the events either. It’s clear that those involved sense that the whole thing could easily be on the nose.

Shocked by neo-Nazi fellow travellers
It’s been a little while since the marches, but I’m still shocked – but why am I surprised? As I repeatedly say Australia is not one country, but two – both parts going in opposite directions, one into the past and one into the future. I’ve written about this in more detail on my ‘indefinite article’ blog, which I describe as ‘irreverent writing about contemporary Australian society, popular culture, the creative economy and the digital and online world – life in the trenches and on the beaches of the information age.’

Unfortunately for the Nazis, they are really on a hiding to nothing – neither the world (nor Australia) is that 'white' and it’s getting less so every day. When China and India really come into their own, watch out. We could easily become no more than a largely irrelevant backwater, hankering for a non-existent past, like the UK is right now. 

'Unfortunately for the Nazis, they are really on a hiding to nothing – neither the world (nor Australia) is that 'white' and it’s getting less so every day. When China and India really come into their own, watch out. We could easily become no more than a largely irrelevant backwater, hankering for a non-existent past, like the UK is right now.'

Who cares about this? Pauline Hanson once moved a motion in Parliament House that 'it was okay to be white'. Does it get any more laughable? In a list of the major existential threats the world needs to be afraid of – and pulling together to deal with – whether it's okay to be pink or not doesn't even scrape in below the bottom of the list.

Looking globally, empire always overreaches itself. Hubris and arrogance bring it down and I expect it will happen with the US and the remaining scraps of UK global standing. Most people were shocked when the Soviet Union suddenly collapsed and broke up, but the underlying signs had been there for decades. If you deal with the world based on your own warped view of how it is, your incompetence will sooner or later produce the results you are geared for. If the Nazis hadn’t invaded Russia or the Japanese hadn’t allied with them and attacked the US, the Nazis might well still control Europe and the Japanese might control Asia – but they don’t. Back then, the US was truly great, but apart from then, unfortunately it's never been that great.

When band of brothers meant something
I keep reflecting that five of my uncles fought the Nazis in World War 2, on torpedo boats, Lancaster bombers and freezing convoys round the top of Norway – luckily they all survived, but many of their friends did not. I don't want us – or our children – to have to refight that war. My father-in law was conscripted into the German Army. He said ‘I've had enough of armies’.
I’ve even been in plenty of marches myself, some of them real ones that completely filled city streets. This one, against closure of remote Aboriginal communities, had a big message, but wasn’t a mass demonstration – when you have enough marchers to shut down a city, you can confidently block the whole street, otherwise it’s best just to wave the flag and make some noise.

One of my uncles was a navigator on the Lancaster bombers that fire-bombed Dresden. My mother-in-law was staying with relatives on the outskirts and watched as the city burned. Here's to never revisiting that horror and that evil and to there being no guarantee of freedom of speech for the sworn enemies of freedom of speech. The people lurking behind (and sometimes in front of) this are as un-Australian as it gets.

‘I keep reflecting that five of my uncles fought the Nazis in World War 2, on torpedo boats, Lancaster bombers and freezing convoys round the top of Norway – luckily they all survived, but many of their friends did not. I don't want us – or our children – to have to refight that war.’

Hanging around like a bad smell
Our noisy pseudo-Nazis (or real Nazis) complain about migrants taking their jobs, but from what I could see from the remnants of the so-called Convoy to Canberra, who hung around Canberra like a bad smell for years afterwards – some of them still here, their rusting pickup trucks parked in out of the way public reserves – many of them seem to be sad loners, who must be surviving on benefits from the welfare state they despise. They seemed to be good at tearing masks off people or breaking elderly people’s wrists, but not much else.

'The real issue is not skin colour but culture and values and that's a worthwhile conversation to have. It's not that I think we should accept potential immigrants uncritically. Instead of asking questions about cricket or other irrelevant matters, we should quiz people about what they think of marriage equality or equal educational opportunity or democracy – or their view of other religions or atheism.'
Bomber aircrew during World War 2 with my uncle Jack (second from right). One of my other uncles, Jim, who was a navigator on a Lancaster bomber used to joke that the rate of attrition amongst the bomber aircrew was so dire that they gave medals to anyone who survived – but I'm sure they didn't give out medals just for turning up.
Room to be choosey
Does anyone really care whether your skin colour is pink or not? The real issue is not skin colour but culture and values and that's a worthwhile conversation to have. It's not that I think we should accept potential immigrants uncritically. Instead of asking questions about cricket or other irrelevant matters, we should quiz people about what they think of marriage equality or equal educational opportunity or democracy – or their view of other religions or atheism. Fail that test and we should say 'thanks, but no thanks – we're sure there is somewhere where you'd feel more at home, but it's not here'. 

I was in Singapore once and in the space of a week or so, it banned a firebrand Muslim cleric and a Christian rabble-rouser, both of whom were keen to visit and speak (and create trouble). Singapore guards its hard-earned cultural diversity well – it knows from bitter experience what the alternative looks like.

If you don’t have something nice to say, don’t say anything
I keep thinking of two pieces of useful advice I picked up somewhere along the way. ‘If you don’t have something nice to say, don’t say anything’ and ‘it’s better not to say anything and risk people people thinking you are a fool, than to open your mouth and confirm it's true’.
My parents and I in the centre of Tasmania in the 1950s, when , unlike now, most of the population could actually remember there had been a World War 2.

I suppose I’ll just get on with being nice to people, neighbourly not nasty, saying hello to strangers, helping elderly people (other than me) across the street – all the things I learned from my parents. That’s why people liked them. According to reports, the Tasmanian counter-protestors against the march sang the INXS song ‘Never tear us apart’ back at the marchers. In Canberra I’m pleased to say, only a thousand people turned up – and two of them were dodgy politicians who were being paid to be there.

‘I suppose I’ll just get on with being nice to people, neighbourly not nasty, saying hello to strangers, helping elderly people (other than me) across the street – all the things I learned from my parents. That’s why people liked them.’

In any city at any time I would guarantee I could find a thousand people who were unhappy with anything you choose to name. Other cities were less encouraging of cultural difference, though. Canberra has a higher level of education and of political literacy than most parts of the country, so that helps in seeing through the rhetoric. As a result of that and many years of being up far too close to hopeless governments (often because we have worked for them), many of us do actually have that mythical and rare Australian bullshit meter that everyone talks about enthusiastically with scant evidence.

© Stephen Cassidy 2025

See also

Walking with ghosts
‘Increasingly people I have known for a long time seem to be dying. In fact my generation is steadily starting to disappear. Who is replacing them? We shuffle along in a world that is unravelling, a world – that for both good and bad – our generation gave birth to. We are teetering in a strange balance between building on the achievements of the past and desperately trying to dismantle them. In many countries, the current generation is poorer than the previous one, upending generations of dreams by working class parents and migrants for a better life for their children. In this time of upheaval – both welcome and unwelcome – creativity is needed like never before’, Walking with ghosts.

On the rails again – a trip about the past and the future
I'm on the road again – well, on the rails again. On Monday I caught the slow train from Canberra to Sydney, and today I’ve woken up to a third morning in Surry Hills. I’m enjoying the days in Sydney – after all, I did live here for twelve and a half years. I’m mainly here to see the Yolngu Power exhibition at the Art Gallery of NSW, which finishes next week, but I’m also using the trip to see to other business’, On the rails again – a trip about the past and the future.

Looking down on dire predictions
‘I see the latest report on looming climate change has some pretty dire predictions – like a future of four times the length of heatwaves, up to five times as many deaths due to extreme heat, a massive drag on productivity, 1.5 million Australians at risk of coastal flooding and a potential half trillion dollar hit to property values by 20250 – and that’s just the good news’, Looking down on dire predictions.

Self-imposed lockdown
'For all their faults and disadvantages there were some positive sides to the pandemic lockdowns. As I often say, ‘good times’ – maybe my memory isn’t what it was. I realise that I planned and prepared for so long to move to an apartment and now I am here I keep discovering more and more things I like about it. I could stay home and read and write and never leave it, just popping down to the shops when I need supplies – perhaps it’s a case of self-imposed lockdown', Self-imposed lockdown.

Essen, trinken, tanzen – aber nicht rauchen
‘From time to time my posts on ‘travelling light’ include references to restaurants we have eaten at or enjoyable places we have stayed. However, most of my regular writing about food, produce, restaurants and places we have stayed is on one of my blogs, tableland, which I describe as: ‘Food and cooking land to table – the daily routine of living in the high country, on the edge of the vast Pacific, just up from Sydney, just down from Mount Kosciuszko’, Essen, trinken, tanzen – aber nicht rauchen.

Cooking minestrone in an art gallery – pineapple fruit cake, hot soup and art on a cold day
‘In winter my mind turns to food, but since it is never turned away from art, cooking and looking manage to fill in the cooler months – or maybe that’s all months. I haven’t made hand-made pasta for a while but I have made sushi and sashimi – though only once in recent memory – as I resurrect all my food traditions. Cooking, eating and cruising around art exhibitions – that’s winter for me’, Cooking minestrone in an art gallery - pineapple fruit cake, hot soup and art on a cold day

Winter markets in a creative city
'The winter we had to have (and could have hoped for) finally arrived on the Southern Tablelands. We have gone back to going to the Farmers Market every week. To add to the winter sun good news arrived. For over ten years we worked to have Canberra listed as a UNESCO Creative City of Design, part of a global network of creative cities. Finally the ACT Government announced that it intended to take the bid forward – and that it had allocated funding for it, the true sign of a government being serious. It’s always a pleasure to help initiate a worthwhile endeavour, but even more of a pleasure to look back ten years later and see that it has been a roaring success in more ways than one', Winter markets in a creative city.

Speaking in tongues
‘Where I live a statue of French maritime hero, La Pérouse, looks out over the suburb as though to say: this, too, could have been France. For a period it seemed everyone who went to school in Australia studied French. Perhaps it was a belated attempt to acknowledge how much better everything would have been if the French had got here first. As I like to say whenever I’m in France, ‘j’ai étudié le Français pendant six ans à l’école’ and I would like to have had more opportunity to use that knowledge', Speaking in tongues.

Looking down on birds
'While the world unravels and some gleefully repeat the mistakes of the past, life goes on in gardens everywhere. I remember that in the Roman Empire, if a change of regime occurred, soldiers, recognising that they were also farmers, would often retire for a time to their farm - until circumstances and duty called them back. Some wit commented that what is happening now is like the fall of the Roman Empire, but with wi-fi', Looking down on birds.

Back in the days when we travelled
'Back in the days when we travelled, I used to post news of my trips to Facebook, so my friends could follow my exploits overseas. For a long time it has been apparent that Facebook has issues, so back in 2019 I set up this blog 'Travelling light' to replace my Facebook posts. However, in the end I decided to stay with Facebook, so this blog was never used', Back in the days when we travelled.

Travelling light by being still
'As I've said repeatedly, I don't have any problem with flying, it's landing and taking off I don't like – and all the logistics in-between. I have few problems with lounging around for hours and on a flight, you get to sit still while people bring you food and drink. How much better does it get?', Travelling light by being still.

Abandoning the world of work
'When I left full-time work over ten years ago, I was asked what I intended to do. Once I no longer had distractions, like work – fun though it was at the time – it was clear that I would definitely have some time on my hands. I replied that I planned to keep up with my friends and to travel – when I wasn't gardening, cooking, reading or writing. It sounded like a fine plan at the time and as things panned out, it WAS a fine plan', Abandoning the world of work.